Author Topic: New EU Treaty  (Read 5492 times)

  • Offline bear

  • Rutabaga
  • Posts: 6,324
  • Global Moderator
  • Hero Member
New EU Treaty
Reply #15 on: December 13, 2007, 16:10:43 PM
Initially a lot of Polish people went to the UK to work but Poland is now developing fast and they are starting to move back.

New EU Treaty
Reply #16 on: December 13, 2007, 16:30:09 PM
Quote from: bear
Initially a lot of Polish people went to the UK to work but Poland is now developing fast and they are starting to move back.


and wheres that money coming from to develop them?
Next in queue will be bulgaria, czech, slovakia, romania, turkey, albania & any other former red curtain country you want to add.

  • Offline bear

  • Rutabaga
  • Posts: 6,324
  • Global Moderator
  • Hero Member
New EU Treaty
Reply #17 on: December 13, 2007, 16:46:52 PM
well sweden UK etc. have to high standard of living and we need to share some of it as we got it by stealing from poor countries in the first place.

Re:New EU Treaty
Reply #18 on: December 13, 2007, 16:50:38 PM
Quote from: Kunal


a) Its worth remember the Euro hasnt crumbled like a lot of people thought it would - were almost coming up to a decade of its use in 2009. Im not saying its perfectly setup, any such endeavor will have teething problems, but I dont see a problem in joining single currency.

It hasnt crumbled no. It did put the price for a lot of items up though - as business round prices up rather than down. - Look at Petrol. 1p tax = 2p price hike. Why? Because 1p + Vat = 1.175p. Shell / Tesco / BP aint going to pay that.. instead its passed on to the consumer who pays 2p. That way Shell / Tesco / BP not only cover the 1p tax increase + the VAT ontop, they make an extra .825p

Quote from: Kunal

b) Cost of goods is largely determined by firstly manufacturing costs and secondly locale; cost of transportation, local taxes, cost of hiring the area required to sell the item. It doesnt suprise me that bread might be cheaper to get to market in Romania than in Germany, just like its probably cheaper in Bradford than in Chelsea. Youll find that pretty much everywhere (outside a Communist country).

I would guess the price difference between bradford & chelsea would be nearer the price of germany. I would assume the price in Romania a lot less.. probably at least 1/2, maybe a 3rd - but a lot of that would depend on Bio Fuel. Currently it makes our bread expensive as farmers are switching to sell their grain to them, meaning theres a shortage of grain to make into bread. - Not sure what its like in Romania.

Quote from: Kunal

You wont find such a price difference in the USA because the States started on more of an equal footing when they formed their Union. That isnt the case with the EU, but that doesnt mean its doomed. Thats the whole point of the system, itll balance itself out over time - prices will rise in Romania (with standard of living) while drop for such items in Germany (because they can be produced where its cheapest and shipped in without extortionate tax costs because its within the Union.)


I am not saying the EU is doomed. I am saying we are doomed. Maybe it will level itself out - well, it should in time over theory, but we would risk an over developed world. Just look at the emergence of China in the last 10 years. Were all paying for that on the fuel pumps & other raw materials like wood, copper, steel, etc.

If everyone had the same standards of living & all able to afford things like Cars, latest TVs, Broadband, etc. Prices would skyrocket.

Now I have no idea the amount of Car owners in a % there are in countries like Turkey, Romania, Poland (as examples).
In the UK & Germany combined, we are looking at near 80million cars.
Population of UK & Germany added together, equal that of Turkey, Romania & Poland. - What do you think thats going to do when Cars become more affordable to them? You get approx 20 gallons of Petrol from a Barrel of Oil.. Currently priced at about £45 a barrel.

New EU Treaty
Reply #19 on: December 13, 2007, 16:53:35 PM
Quote from: bear
well sweden UK etc. have to high standard of living and we need to share some of it as we got it by stealing from poor countries in the first place.


And whats a good standard of living include?

Good selections of food & drink?
Central Heating?
Cars / Transport?

There needs to be a Pyramid system. There needs to be developed, developing & 3rd world countries.

If theres to many developed countries, then natural resources will be used more & used up quicker. Both will increase demand & the later increase prices.

  • Offline Sam

  • Posts: 3,943
  • Hero Member
Re:New EU Treaty
Reply #20 on: December 13, 2007, 17:39:18 PM
Quote from: Eggtastico

I very much doubt you would find such a high cost of living difference in the USA.


Yes you do! Here in PA you pay way way more than in Delware and NJ for alcohol. This is because PA state govt controls alcohol sales and sets the prices. In delaware and NJ they dont. Philadelphia is only a few minutes from both Delware and NJ and people nip across the state border for christmas booze. You are paying £5 for a bottle of wine that is £3 elsewhere.

Fireworks are illegal in NJ. You cannot buy them. People from NJ nip across the border to PA to get fireworks for Christmas.

Another example is sales tax. PA is 6%, 7% in Philly centre, and 0% in delaware. Wanna buy a new TV for Christmas? Nip across the state border and save.

And the biggest example is property. In the north east its quite expensive,  around the same as buying in the north of england. Go down to Alabama and they are giving houses away. Because the southern states are similar to our Eastern European countries - way poorer.

  • Offline Sam

  • Posts: 3,943
  • Hero Member
New EU Treaty
Reply #21 on: December 13, 2007, 17:42:13 PM
Quote from: Eggtastico
Quote from: bear
Initially a lot of Polish people went to the UK to work but Poland is now developing fast and they are starting to move back.


and wheres that money coming from to develop them?
Next in queue will be bulgaria, czech, slovakia, romania, turkey, albania & any other former red curtain country you want to add.


Countries can become richer without others becoming poorer.
The cake can become bigger. That is capitalism.

If you were correct, then we would all still be farmers.

Re:New EU Treaty
Reply #22 on: December 13, 2007, 18:44:10 PM
Quote from: Sam
Quote from: Eggtastico

I very much doubt you would find such a high cost of living difference in the USA.


Yes you do! Here in PA you pay way way more than in Delware and NJ for alcohol. This is because PA state govt controls alcohol sales and sets the prices. In delaware and NJ they dont. Philadelphia is only a few minutes from both Delware and NJ and people nip across the state border for christmas booze. You are paying £5 for a bottle of wine that is £3 elsewhere.

Fireworks are illegal in NJ. You cannot buy them. People from NJ nip across the border to PA to get fireworks for Christmas.

Another example is sales tax. PA is 6%, 7% in Philly centre, and 0% in delaware. Wanna buy a new TV for Christmas? Nip across the state border and save.

And the biggest example is property. In the north east its quite expensive,  around the same as buying in the north of england. Go down to Alabama and they are giving houses away. Because the southern states are similar to our Eastern European countries - way poorer.


Try doing it without using alcohol as an example. Alcohol is a huge generator in Tax.
Try maybe, Bread, Milk, Sugar, Coffee, Vegetables, etc.
Sales tax is down to individual states. Its difficult to compare states of america to the nations of the EU. House prices are priced on Demand.
The UK is small country with big population, hence our house prices are so high.

New EU Treaty
Reply #23 on: December 13, 2007, 18:58:18 PM
Quote from: Sam
Quote from: Eggtastico
Quote from: bear
Initially a lot of Polish people went to the UK to work but Poland is now developing fast and they are starting to move back.


and wheres that money coming from to develop them?
Next in queue will be bulgaria, czech, slovakia, romania, turkey, albania & any other former red curtain country you want to add.


Countries can become richer without others becoming poorer.
The cake can become bigger. That is capitalism.

If you were correct, then we would all still be farmers.


That has nothing at all to do with what your quoting me for.

Simple fact is, the more developed nations we have, the higher demand for goods & services. The trees will need to be chopped down for furniture, the more Ore will be needed for Iron, Steel, Copper products. The more Oil will be needed for Fuel, Heating & Electric.

Like ive said, Our fuel prices are high because of the Emergence of China - The War thats going on does have an affect, but if the war ended tomorrow, prices wouldnt fall back to where they was before all this gulf nonsense started.
India & China both have populations of over 1 billion (1,000 million) Each.
The Whole of Europe is about 750 million & Africa is about 1 billion also.

India & China are developing faster than anyone else.

Probably where we at now is that around 1.5 billion (my estimates) live in world where we have choices for groceries, buy what clothing we like, Cars, heated homes, etc. - Fully Developed Nations.
In 10-20 years when the rest of Eastern Europe catch up along with the vast majority of russia, india, china, turkey, etc. we would be looking at nearer 5 billion. more than 3 folds where we are now. plus the billion or so still left in africa who are also bound to develop out of 3rd world poverty & into the 2nd world.

Do you think the planet has the resources for that? if were paying £1 a litre now for 1.5billion people... whats not to say well be paying the equivelent of £3 a litre when theres 5billion wanting the fuel?

  • Offline Sam

  • Posts: 3,943
  • Hero Member
New EU Treaty
Reply #24 on: December 13, 2007, 19:32:08 PM
Who cares if we have to pay £3 a litre. We can switch to electric cars tomorrow if we had to.

  • Offline Sam

  • Posts: 3,943
  • Hero Member
Re:New EU Treaty
Reply #25 on: December 13, 2007, 19:32:52 PM
Quote from: Eggtastico

Try maybe, Bread, Milk, Sugar, Coffee, Vegetables, etc.
Sales tax is down to individual states. Its difficult to compare states of america to the nations of the EU. House prices are priced on Demand.
The UK is small country with big population, hence our house prices are so high.



Bread and milk in the usa is far more expensive than in the UK (my experience is limited to PA though but its not a particularly expensive state). They dont have any real supermarket competition.

Its like $1.80 for the crappest loaf of supermarket own bread (and a tiny loaf at that). $3.69 I paid for a loaf from the bakery section.

Re:New EU Treaty
Reply #26 on: December 13, 2007, 19:38:10 PM
but throughout the USA they are priced more or less the same give or take a few cents?

Or is the difference as much as it would be between the UK & say Romania?

But Bread is on the rise worldwide because of Bio Fuel. Farmers are getting more for their grain for Bio companies than they are from those who want to turn it into flour.

  • Offline Sam

  • Posts: 3,943
  • Hero Member
New EU Treaty
Reply #27 on: December 13, 2007, 20:11:21 PM
UK and Romania is a bad example. Youve picked two ends of the scale, and romania has only been in the EU for 1 year (not even). Give it 10 years and see. Like Czech - their prices are becoming in line with ours now.

New EU Treaty
Reply #28 on: December 13, 2007, 20:37:34 PM
Quote from: Sam
UK and Romania is a bad example. Youve picked two ends of the scale, and romania has only been in the EU for 1 year (not even). Give it 10 years and see. Like Czech - their prices are becoming in line with ours now.


which is exactly my point... Where is the money going to come from for Romania to develop?
Where has the money come from for Czech Republic to develop? FWIW, their prices are nowhere near ours. £1.50 for a pint of stella in Prague 1. Equivelent place in the UK would cost £3.50

  • Offline Paulus

  • Posts: 212
  • Full Member
New EU Treaty
Reply #29 on: December 13, 2007, 21:46:05 PM
Quote

which is exactly my point... Where is the money going to come from for Romania to develop?
Where has the money come from for Czech Republic to develop? FWIW, their prices are nowhere near ours. £1.50 for a pint of stella in Prague 1. Equivelent place in the UK would cost £3.50

You can still get a good pint of beer in Prague for 50p

That said they are the highest consumers of beer in the world and they have loads of breweries in and around the city so you would expect the beer prices to be lower.

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.