How does Caol Ila rank?
Got some in my room and think its lovely for its smoothness. But can I do lots better?
Depends on if you want strong flavour or alcohol content, they are definitely not the same. Caol Ila is rated one of the lighter Islay malts, thats not to say its going to be weak flavoured, on average Islays are amongst the strongest flavoured whiskys going.
As far as doing better, providing you like it - drink it
I certainly wouldnt discribe it as a beginners malt. If it proves too strong of flavour then Glenfiddich or one of the other speyside whiskys are well worth trying.
[edit] good informative site on whisky...
http://www.whisky-distilleries.info/Caol%20Ila_EN.shtml[/edit]